Carrie Underwood

Back in 2005, a country sensation took the stage and left Simon Cowell and Randy Jackson in awe with her mesmerizing rendition of “I Can’t Make You Love Me.” Yet, before she wowed the judges, she couldn’t help but spill some tantalizing secrets about herself. It turns out we can welcome her to the exclusive “nipple crew.” Carrie Underwood, the singing sensation, was born with an extra nipple, a condition known as Polymastia or Polythelia.

With candor, Carrie confessed, “It looked like a mole. But it was a third nipple.” Nonetheless, she eventually opted to have it removed. While having an extra nipple may be relatively rare, it’s not an entirely unheard-of phenomenon. According to a 2018 study, a sneaky extra nip graces the anatomy of at least 5% of the population, and many choose to part ways with this intriguing feature through surgery.