#12: Katy Perry and Missy Elliott

Never doubt Katy Perry’s showmanship—she went all in for a gloriously over-the-top Vegas-style spectacle, complete with psychedelic dancing palm trees and, of course, Left Shark. But the real jaw-dropper came when a mysterious silhouette emerged, as the unmistakable beat of “Get Ur Freak On” played.

No. It couldn’t be. It was. Missy Freaking Elliott, making her long-awaited comeback, stealing the show with the moment we’d all been waiting for. Credit to Katy—only a true star has the confidence to share the Super Bowl stage with a legend and still hold her own. And yes, Left Shark remains undefeated.