Pretzel Wands!
These are an epic idea for a witch-themed party! One of the classier items on the list, these yogurt, and chocolate-dipped pretzels, could be served to the Queen of England without complaint! The teacup is an excellent addition to the photo, too, though I’m not sure about the mushrooms.

The wands and mushrooms look so real; I’m not sure I’d eat them without someone telling me it’s okay, first. There are some true culinary artists out there, and while this is a simple set-up, mine would be an absolute disaster zone if I tried to recreate them.