Stanley Tucci and John Krasinski
All right, this is our first time seeing a celebrity appear twice on this list; it’s Stanley Tucci and his literary agent wife, Felicity Blunt, who appear here. But now we’ve got some contradictory information. The first person said that he tipped really well, while this one said that he tipped really poorly.

What can account for this discrepancy? Maybe the service was really poor the second time. Maybe the food was really bad. Maybe someone had stolen his wallet and he didn’t have any cash. Personally, I’m inclined to give old Stanley the benefit of the doubt. He seems like a dependable guy.