#34: Lucky Guess?
There have been a few times in my life where I’ve managed to make a lucky guess, but nothing this random and perfect. They should have signed up for The Price is Right. I bet they would have been brilliant at it! I mean, if you can guess this, you can guess the right door of the price of a can of beans!

If we’re sticking with a mainstream theory, then this person probably noticed something about the card if it was visible. Either that or the little motel had Christmas cards they sent out and told them, which they both promptly forgot. I’m sure it’s something along those lines, but the brain power here is definitely usable for a good gain!