#2: Your Average Shaker Heights Family

Newman’s father, Arthur, owned a successful sporting goods business, expecting Paul to take over the family trade eventually. However, his mother, Theresa, saw something different in him. A lover of the arts, she encouraged his passion for acting, enrolling him in school plays and supporting his dreams even when they seemed impractical.

This parental divide—his father’s pragmatism versus his mother’s creative spirit—left Newman between two worlds. When he later pursued acting as a career, his father wasn’t thrilled. But his mother? She clipped every newspaper article about him, proudly keeping a scrapbook of his rise to fame.