#5: Lexus SC 430

Price: $68,405

The Lexus SC 430 captivates existing fans but fails to impress non-loyalists. Initially a coupe, its makeover into a sporty convertible didn’t compensate for its poor handling and disappointing resale value, falling short of sportive expectations.

Priced more for its aesthetics than performance, the SC 430 has been critically received as a car that prioritizes style over-engineering. The Truth About Cars notably criticized its design, suggesting that its hefty price doesn’t reflect its quality.