#23: Alyssa Milano

This Easter throwback of a young Alyssa Milano is adorable and surreal. Rocking pigtails and a huge smile, she looks completely unbothered by the fact that the Easter Bunny beside her has a face that might haunt dreams.

It’s a peak vintage mall photo—pink tones, velvet drapes, and a more “mysterious mascot” costume than a cuddly cartoon. But that’s what makes it so great. There’s something so innocent about kids entirely buying into the holiday magic, even when the bunny looks a little off.