36. Nev Shulman

Location: Smashburger

Initial cost: Unknown

Amount added: $926*

While dining at SmashBurger in the Denver International Airport, Catfish host Nev Shulman encountered a pregnant server, Zulia Reyes. Moved by her situation, he engaged kindly, inquiring about her due date, showing an immediate and personal interest in her well-being.

In a remarkable twist of fate, Reyes’ due date coincided with Shulman’s birthday, September 26, prompting him to leave a generous $926 tip—an ode to their shared special date. Shulman also left a note of congratulations for Reyes on her impending motherhood, highlighting his thoughtful nature.