#34: The Mysterious Crawl Space Discovery

Where? North Dakota

When? 1915

In 1915, a chilling discovery was made in the small town of Niagara, North Dakota. Though it never grew beyond a modest population—today, it hovers under 100—the town harbored a dark secret in the early 20th century.

The remnants of six unidentified individuals, tragically bludgeoned to death, were unearthed within the confines of Eugene Butler’s former home’s crawl space. Butler, known for his reclusiveness, passed away in 1911 after years in a mental institution, leaving the origins and identities of these victims cloaked in mystery.