#9: Lenny Dykstra

Nicknamed “Nailz,” Lenny Dykstra was known for his fearless, all-out playing style, making him a fan favorite. His gritty approach, frequent brawls, and refusal to back down helped power the 1986 Mets and 1993 Phillies to memorable postseason runs.

Dykstra’s tenacity on the field defined his baseball persona—relentless, scrappy, and always in the fight. However, his post-baseball life has been far less heroic. Plagued by a series of legal troubles and personal controversies, Dykstra’s reputation took a sharp turn.